Best Tomato Pie Recipe

When I first stumbled upon this Best Tomato Pie Recipe, I knew it was a keeper. It’s such a wonderful celebration of summertime tomatoes – juicy, vibrant, and layered with all the comfort you want in a savory pie. I love this because it’s simple enough for weeknight dinners but impressive enough to bring to a potluck or family gathering. You’ll find that each bite bursts with fresh tomato flavor balanced by cheesy richness and the subtle zing of hot sauce.

What makes this pie truly special is how the tomatoes are prepped to avoid sogginess, a trick I discovered after a few trial runs. Once you get the hang of draining the tomatoes well, you’re rewarded with a perfectly flaky crust and no watery mess. The Best Tomato Pie Recipe is versatile, too – switch up the cheeses or herbs to make it your own. Trust me, once you try it, your family is going to go crazy for this pie as much as mine does!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

Each ingredient in this Best Tomato Pie Recipe works together to create a harmonious flavor and texture. Using ripe, juicy tomatoes is essential, and a mix of sharp and melty cheeses provides richness without overwhelming freshness.

• Pie shell: Whether homemade or store-bought, a sturdy crust is your pie’s foundation—pre-baking it prevents sogginess.
• Large tomatoes: Choose firm, ripe tomatoes for the best flavor and proper moisture control.
• Kosher salt: Perfect for drawing out excess moisture from the tomatoes without overpowering the flavor.
• Yellow or red onion: Adds a mild sweetness and crunch; finely chopped keeps it subtle but noticeable.
• Fresh basil: Thinly sliced, it brings a fragrant herbal note that pairs beautifully with tomatoes.
• Grated cheese: A combination like sharp cheddar and Monterey Jack or Gruyere for depth and meltability.
• Mayonnaise: Adds creaminess and a slight tang to the cheese mixture, keeping the pie moist.
• Hot sauce (like Frank’s or Tabasco): Just a splash to add subtle heat and complexity.
• Freshly ground black pepper: For seasoning and a little bite.

Variations

I like to experiment a bit depending on what I have on hand or what flavors I’m craving. Feel free to personalize this Best Tomato Pie Recipe — you can make it simpler or jazz it up with extras. Imagining your own twist is half the fun!

• Cheese swap: I once replaced cheddar and Monterey Jack with Gruyere and a bit of mozzarella, and it added a lovely nuttiness and stretchiness that everyone loved.
• Herbs: Try fresh thyme or oregano if basil isn’t available — they give a slightly earthier flavor that’s still great with tomato.
• Spice it up: Add a pinch of smoked paprika or cayenne instead of hot sauce for a different heat profile.
• Crust ideas: Using a garlic butter crust gives the pie an extra savory kick that pairs amazingly with the filling.

How to Make Best Tomato Pie Recipe

Step 1: Preheat and Prepare Your Crust

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C) and positioning the rack in the middle. If you’re using a store-bought pie shell, follow the package directions for pre-baking, usually around 8-10 minutes until it’s just lightly browned. For homemade crust, I like to freeze it for 30 minutes first—this helps keep the edges from shrinking. Then, press a sheet of foil inside and fill it with pie weights like dry beans or rice before baking for 15 minutes. Remove the foil and weights, poke holes in the bottom with a fork to vent, and bake for another 10 minutes so it’s fully ready for the filling.

Step 2: Chop, Salt, and Drain the Tomatoes

This is the trickiest part but super important: half your tomatoes and squeeze out as much juice as you can. I usually do this over a bowl with a colander to catch the juice, then sprinkle them with kosher salt to draw out even more moisture. Let them drain while your crust bakes. Once they’ve rested, roughly chop the tomatoes to get about 3 cups to layer in the pie. I also like to squeeze the chopped tomatoes again using towels or even a potato ricer to really avoid sogginess inside the pie.

Step 3: Layer the Onions, Tomatoes, and Basil

Spread your finely chopped onions evenly over the baked pie crust—it adds that subtle crunch and sweetness that balances the tomatoes. Then distribute your drained, chopped tomatoes on top of the onions, making sure you don’t add too much moisture back in. Finish this layer with thinly sliced fresh basil; the aroma at this stage makes my mouth water every time.

Step 4: Mix Cheese, Mayo & Hot Sauce, then Spread

In a medium bowl, combine your grated cheese blend with mayonnaise, a teaspoon or so of your favorite hot sauce (I use Frank’s but Tabasco works great), and a good grind of black pepper. This creamy topping pulls all the flavors of tomato and herb together. Then spread this cheesy mixture evenly over the basil-tomato layer, being generous enough to cover the top but not so much it overwhelms.

Step 5: Bake Until Golden and Bubbly

Bake the pie at 350°F (175°C) for about 25 to 45 minutes. I keep a close eye after the 25-minute mark to catch that perfect golden brown top with bubbling cheese underneath. Every oven’s a little different, so look for those visual clues. Once finished, let it cool for 10 minutes before slicing so the filling sets nicely.

How to Serve Best Tomato Pie Recipe

Garnishes

I usually sprinkle a little extra fresh basil and a crack of black pepper right before serving to brighten up each slice. Sometimes I drizzle a tiny bit of good olive oil for that silky touch. These simple garnishes bring freshness and a little pop of color that makes the dish inviting.

Side Dishes

A crisp green salad, like arugula with lemon vinaigrette, pairs perfectly with the richness of the pie. I also love serving it alongside roasted or grilled vegetables to keep things balanced and seasonal.

Creative Ways to Present

For special occasions, I’ve cut this pie into mini tartlets using a muffin pan—everyone loved the individual portions! Another fun idea is to arrange a colorful assortment of heirloom tomatoes sliced on top before baking for a stunning visual effect that tastes just as amazing.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I wrap leftover tomato pie tightly with plastic wrap and keep it in the fridge for up to 3 days. It reheats beautifully and loses none of its charm when warmed gently. Just make sure to cover it well to avoid drying out the crust.

Freezing

Freezing tomato pie works, but I recommend wrapping slices individually in foil and placing them in a freezer-safe bag. When you thaw them overnight in the fridge and reheat in the oven, the crust stays flaky, and the filling tastes almost as fresh as day one.

Reheating

I reheat leftovers in a 350°F oven for about 10-15 minutes until warmed through and the crust crisps back up. Microwaving can make the crust soggy, so the oven method is my preferred go-to for maintaining texture and flavor.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Best Tomato Pie Recipe holds a special place in my heart – it’s the perfect way to showcase fresh tomatoes with minimal fuss for maximum flavor. Cooking it feels like sharing a warm moment with friends in my kitchen. I can’t wait for you to try making this pie your own; I promise, once you do, it’ll become your go-to summertime favorite too. Serve it warm, share it freely, and enjoy every flaky, cheesy bite!

Print